News > Bladder leaks > Product comparisons

American Men Rate Leak-Proof Underwear: Which Brand Comes Out on Top?

We looked at 5 popular brands across the US. Here's what we found.

Advertorial

By the Prime Men's Health product desk. Updated October 30, 2026.

5

brands evaluated

6

scoring criteria

All brand names shown are the property of their respective owners.

Leak-proof underwear has become one of the most talked-about switches in men's health over the past few years. More and more men are choosing to move away from disposable pads, guards and pull-ups, and for good reason. Washable leak-proof underwear is reusable, comfortable, and can save you a significant amount of money over time.

But not all leak-proof underwear is created equal. Some pairs offer reliable protection for up to 12 hours. Others let you down the first time you sit down. Some feel like regular boxer briefs. Others feel bulky, stay damp, or simply do not stay in place.

With so many brands now available, from drugstore names to online bestsellers to specialist brands, it can be genuinely difficult to know where to start.

That is why we decided to run an in-depth comparison of men's leak-proof underwear available in the US. We evaluated 5 of the most popular brands available today, analyzed feedback from men across the country, and report back honestly on what worked, what did not, and what we would actually recommend to a friend.

The brands in our comparison: Menvault, Wearever, Depend, Carer and YESWEL.

See which brand came out on top ↓

Assessment criteria

Each pair was scored from 1 to 10 on the six criteria below, built around the problems men run into most with leak-proof underwear. The first two, leaks staying in and real capacity, count most toward the overall score, because they decide whether you stay dry.

Leaks stay in

Does urine stay inside when you sit, stand up, bend or lie down?

What usually goes wrong: padding that stops short of the fly, and loose leg openings.

Real capacity

Does it hold what the label says?

What usually goes wrong: pairs sold for moderate leaks that only handle a sneeze.

Dry and odor-free

Does it keep wetness off your skin and smell in check, during wear and after washing?

What usually goes wrong: damp by evening, and a smell that survives the wash.

Fit, sizing and staying put

Is it true to size, and does it stay put all day?

What usually goes wrong: runs small, rides up, stretches out by afternoon.

Looks like regular underwear

Would anyone notice under a pair of khakis?

What usually goes wrong: bulk at the front.

Holds up in the wash

Does the padding stay flat and absorbent after weeks of washing?

What usually goes wrong: padding that bunches and won't lie flat again.

The overall score is the weighted average of the six, rounded to one decimal.

Summary score table

Here is how all 5 brands scored overall.

Rank

Brand

Overall score

#1

Excellent

9.2

#2

Wearever

Good

7.3

#3

Depend

Fair

6.6

#4

Carer

Below average

6.1

#5

YESWEL

Below average

6.0

Detailed scorecards per brand

#1 Winner

Menvault All-Day Protection Boxer Briefs

9.2 / 10

Cut

Boxer brief

Stated capacity

Up to 10.14 fl oz (300 ml)

Price

$99.95 for 4 (about $25 a pair)

Stated wash life

Hundreds of washes

Cut

Boxer brief

Stated capacity

Up to 10.14 fl oz (300 ml)

Price

$99.95 for 4 (about $25 a pair)

Stated wash life

Hundreds of washes

Criterion

Our assessment

Score

Leaks stay in

The absorbent layers cover the front, back and inner leg sides, not just the middle. That wider coverage keeps leaks in when you sit down, stand up or bend over.

9.6

Real capacity

Rated to hold up to 10.14 fl oz (300 ml) for up to 12 hours, about double the next-best pair in our comparison. On heavier days, the included washable guard adds extra protection. It isn't designed for a full bladder release.

9.4

Dry and odor-free

A wicking top layer and OEKO-TEX certified bamboo keep wetness away from the skin and odor in check. It can feel warm in hot weather.

9.0

Fit, sizing and staying put

Sizes S to 8XL, backed by a fit guarantee: if your first size isn't right, you can exchange it.

8.8

Looks like regular underwear

A regular boxer brief cut that looks and feels like everyday boxers under your clothes, though it's a little heavier than a regular pair.

9.0

Holds up in the wash

Well made and built to last: the padding stays flat and absorbent wash after wash, and the pair is made to hold up for hundreds of washes. It does take longer to air dry than regular underwear.

9.0

Overall rating: Excellent

9.2

Menvault stood out as the most complete leak-proof underwear in our comparison, and the only pair built around where men actually leak. Its nine-layer absorbent zone wraps the front, back and inner legs instead of sitting in the middle, and that is exactly where the other four lost the most points. It also has the highest stated capacity we found, nearly a full can of soda, in a regular boxer brief cut.

It's also the only pair in our comparison with a reusable backup. Every pair comes with a washable guard that fits into a built-in pocket, so it stays in place. Add it on heavier days or long outings, and leave it out when you don't need it.

With the current Buy 2, Get 2 Free offer, you get four pairs for $99.95, about $25 a pair, each with its own washable guard.

Worth knowing before you buy

  • Every pair comes with one washable, reusable guard
  • Sold only at menvault.com
  • Three colors: black, navy and gray
  • No fly opening
  • Takes longer to air dry than regular underwear, so plan on about 4 pairs

Best for: light to moderate leaks, active days and long days at work, and men who are done with pads.

Check availability

2nd place

Wearever Men's Boxer Brief, Regular Absorbency

7.3 / 10

Cut

Boxer brief, button fly

Stated capacity

150 ml (up to 5 oz a day)

Price

$21.95 a pair

Stated wash life

200 to 250 washes

Cut

Boxer brief, button fly

Stated capacity

150 ml (up to 5 oz a day)

Price

$21.95 a pair

Stated wash life

200 to 250 washes

Criterion

Our assessment

Score

Leaks stay in

The padding stops short of the fly and the back, and the loose front can let flow miss the pad. Coverage is Wearever's biggest weakness.

7.0

Real capacity

Rated at 150 ml. Wearever's own listing describes it for small leaks of 1 to 2 oz and says it isn't meant for sustained streams.

7.2

Dry and odor-free

A cotton and wool pad that keeps odor in check, though the crotch sags once it's wet.

7.4

Fit, sizing and staying put

Comfortable, and comfort is where it scores best. Sizing is the weak spot: it tends to run loose.

7.0

Looks like regular underwear

A real boxer brief with a working button fly, though the pad adds some bulk.

8.0

Holds up in the wash

Rated for 200 to 250 washes, the longest in our comparison, and it washes well.

8.2

Overall rating: Good

7.3

Wearever is the strongest alternative in our comparison. It's a family-owned American brand that has been around since 2002, makes a real boxer brief with a working fly, and has the longest stated wash life in the group. Where it loses ground is coverage. Its own listing describes it for small leaks of 1 to 2 oz, and the padding doesn't reach far enough toward the fly and the back for heavier days.

Best for: light, predictable dribbles, and men who want a fly.

3rd place

Depend Washable Underwear for Men

6.6 / 10

Cut

Brief, no fly

Stated capacity

"Light," no volume given

Price

$15.84 a pair

Stated wash life

Replace after 30 washes

Cut

Brief, no fly

Stated capacity

"Light," no volume given

Price

$15.84 a pair

Stated wash life

Replace after 30 washes

Criterion

Our assessment

Score

Leaks stay in

Fine for light leaks, but the absorbent pad doesn't extend far enough for anything more.

6.8

Real capacity

Sold as light absorbency with no volume rating. Fine for drips, but not built for heavier leaks.

6.2

Dry and odor-free

Built-in odor control, but it can feel quite wet by evening and a little warm in summer.

7.0

Fit, sizing and staying put

Runs very small, in some cases even after sizing up.

6.4

Looks like regular underwear

Comfortable, but a brief cut rather than a boxer brief.

7.2

Holds up in the wash

The package itself says to replace it after 30 washes.

6.0

Overall rating: Fair

6.6

Depend is the name you know from every drugstore aisle, and this pair does the job for light drips. It's also upfront about its limits: the package says light absorbency and replace after 30 washes. If you leak more than a few drips, or you want a boxer brief rather than a brief, it drops down the list.

Best for: light drips, and men who want a brand name they recognize.

4th place

Carer Men's Washable Incontinence Underwear

6.1 / 10

Cut

Brief, front fly

Stated capacity

150 ml (5 oz)

Price

$44.99 for 3 (about $15 a pair)

Stated wash life

Not stated

Cut

Brief, front fly

Stated capacity

150 ml (5 oz)

Price

$44.99 for 3 (about $15 a pair)

Stated wash life

Not stated

Criterion

Our assessment

Score

Leaks stay in

Leaks are its most common failure, mostly down to leg openings that aren't snug enough.

6.2

Real capacity

Rated at 150 ml, but it absorbs less than that rating suggests and is best kept for small accidents.

6.4

Dry and odor-free

Odor can linger, and a regular wash doesn't always get the smell out.

6.2

Fit, sizing and staying put

Sizing is inconsistent and mostly runs small, and the fabric stretches out during the day.

5.6

Looks like regular underwear

A brief cut that tends to sit baggy.

6.6

Holds up in the wash

Its weakest point: the pad tends to bunch up after washing and won't lie flat again.

5.4

Overall rating: Below average

6.1

Carer is one of the best-selling washable options online, and it has a front fly. The pad is the problem. Bunching after washing is its biggest weakness, and with loose leg openings and sizing that runs small, it's hard to recommend beyond light use at home.

Best for: trying washables on a budget, for light leaks at home.

5th place

YESWEL Men's Incontinence Boxer Briefs

6.0 / 10

Cut

Boxer brief

Stated capacity

100 ml (3.4 oz)

Price

$39.99 for 3 (about $13 a pair)

Stated wash life

Not stated

Cut

Boxer brief

Stated capacity

100 ml (3.4 oz)

Price

$39.99 for 3 (about $13 a pair)

Stated wash life

Not stated

Criterion

Our assessment

Score

Leaks stay in

The weakest leak protection in our comparison, including leaks when lying down.

5.8

Real capacity

Rated at 100 ml, the lowest here. On a heavier day it can soak through in about an hour.

5.8

Dry and odor-free

A soft cotton inner layer that's gentle on the skin, but there's no wicking layer to pull wetness away.

6.4

Fit, sizing and staying put

It rides up between the thighs and bunches at the front.

6.0

Looks like regular underwear

Looks like a regular boxer brief, apart from some bulk at the front.

6.8

Holds up in the wash

Durability is a weak point, from split stitching to elastic that stretches out after a few washes.

5.6

Overall rating: Below average

6.0

YESWEL is the cheapest per pair and looks like a regular boxer brief, and it's fine for occasional drips. But it has the lowest stated capacity in our comparison and the weakest leak protection, including at night.

Best for: occasional drips only.

Our verdict, and the clear winner

Based on our evaluation, one thing is clear: not all leak-proof underwear delivers on its promises. The difference between the best and the rest was biggest on three things: keeping leaks in at the leg and fly, how much each pair actually holds, and staying dry against the skin.

Menvault stood well ahead of the rest on all three. It covers the front, back and inner legs, holds up to 10.14 fl oz for up to 12 hours, and keeps wetness away from the skin with bamboo layers. It's also the only pair here that comes with a washable guard for heavier days. Wearever came closest and is a solid choice for light, predictable dribbles. But for reliable all-day protection that looks and feels like regular underwear, Menvault is our clear recommendation.

Check availability

How to get Menvault at the best possible price

Menvault is only available through its own website, not at CVS, Walgreens or on Amazon. When we checked, it was running a Fall Sale on bundles, and some sizes sell out between restocks, so check yours first.

1Measure your waist and pick your size. Sizes run from S to 8XL, and the size chart is on the product page. If you get it wrong, Menvault's fit guarantee covers you.

2Start with 4 pairs. They take longer to air dry than regular underwear, so this way one is always clean and dry. Machine wash cool, inside out, skip the fabric softener, and hang to dry.

3Wear them on a normal day. If they don't work for you, you're covered by Menvault's 30-day money-back guarantee.

Buy 2, Get 2 Free

4 pairs for $99.95 $159.80, 
about $25 a pair

Free discreet shipping
30-day money-back guarantee
Washable guard for heavier days

Buying for your husband or dad? Measure his waist in inches and use the size chart on the product page. It ships in plain, discreet packaging.

Check availability

Only available at menvault.com

What Menvault customers are saying

Rated 4.3 / 5 on Trustpilot

Owen Carney

US

Finally an incontinence boxer brief that performs!

I’d been using generic Amazon guards for the past few years, and they seemed to do the trick. But not always, so I started to look at Menvault and similar products. First, boxers took some getting used to as I’d worn only briefs for decades. The actual incontinence briefs on the market were a joke…might as well just been overpriced normal briefs with zero absorbency. Tried several brands of boxer briefs at various price points which also lacked absorbency. Finally decided to try Menvault. I am totally pleased with them. The level of absorbency is what the should be. Comfort and fit are great. I just wish I had tried them sooner. I have already placed my second order. The only drawback I have found is the l-o-n-g drying time. Other than that, I find only pros and no cons with Menvault.

Date of review: September 26, 2026

Wm winchester

US

Designed for men.

These are the first pair of underwear that I’ve tried for incontinence (and I’ve literally tried them all) that are created for male anatomy… Most pads in other underwear assume your anatomy always points straight down and never moves. The truth is things down there move around. Menvault underwear allow you to correct for this. Brilliant.

Date of review: July 25, 2026

Jim

US

I just tried my new menvault boxer…

I just tried my new menvault boxer briefs yesterday. They are much more comfortable than full pull-ups and guards. For the first time wearing I used the additional pad for mental comfort and it worked well. I will next try without the additional pad to see how that works. The moisture from any leaks or dribbles wicks away and I don’t feel it … which is terrific. Thus far I’m very pleased with the Menvault boxer brief

Date of review: September 28, 2026

Jim Woody Anderson

US

I Went By Hip Size More Than Waist Size and they fit great

My waist is 38" but my hips are 41". The chart showed a 38" waist was XL, but my hip size showed I was a Large. Regular underwear also says Large. I knew the XL Hip would be way too big, so I opted for the Large. The MV boxers fit great, nice and snug. I only use them at night and so far, no leaks. I even sleep better knowing when an accident happens, the mattress is protected. The MV boxers are comfortable and not hot at all. Customer Service is excellent. I had a question and submitted it around 1PM and receive a reply by 6PM.

Date of review: June 16, 2026

Mac

US

I ordered the wrong size

I ordered the wrong size, totally my mistake. When I reached out, the customer service was top shelf. Got my size sorted out quickly and the new order arrived in a timely manner. I will say that sizing is crucial to good performance. That being said, once the proper size is being used the performance of the product is great. Much more comfortable than a pull up and works better The product looks just like boxer briefs And that has been a real confidence booster. All in all 10 for 10 Last note, they do take a fair amount of time to dry so have enough to rotate if you wear them daily.

Date of review: July 15, 2026

Lonnie

US

After reading about the Menvault under ware I’m a very satisfied customer.

After reading about the Menvault under ware I wanted to give them a try in an effort to save myself the embarrassing time of having dribbles on my pants while out in the public. Gave them a try and I had a fit issue upon arrival. I contacted Menvault and they helped me with getting the correct size and sent me 5 new pairs for only the shipping costs. I must say I’m very impressed with the product and the customer service I received. I highly recommend this product to anyone who is considering them.

Date of review: June 22, 2026

Marc Haslam

CA

Worth every penny!

After considerable research into similar products I made the decision that Menvault was the right product for me. I couldn’t be happier! I can last an entire day at work and not worry about pad changes or pullups that feel like a wet swimsuit. I bought 5 pairs so I always have a washed and dry pair to start the next day. I have an upcoming trip to Europe and will likely buy two more pairs to keep me supplied between my destinations. This product works!

Date of review: May 22, 2026

R Hacker

US

Great Product for an old guy (or a young guy) with bladder control issues

Great Product for an old guy (or a young guy) with bladder control issues. They allow me to live with confidence for the entire day. They have saved times of embarrassment many times. Nice high quality product and comfortable. Shipping was super. Excellent company to do business with.

Date of review: July 28, 2026

Check availability

How we evaluated, and our sources

Each pair was scored from 1 to 10 on the six criteria above. For every brand, our scores combine the product's specifications and the brand's own claims (capacity, layers, materials and wash life), its cut and construction, its price, and feedback from verified customers. The overall score is a weighted average, with leak protection and real capacity counting most. Prices were checked in October 2026.

Straight talk on men's health,
from men who've been there