Menvault All-Day Protection Boxer Briefs genuinely impressed me. An easy 5 stars ★★★★★. These are the first leak-proof underwear that actually look and feel like normal boxer briefs, not medical kit.
I tested them during golf, an office meeting, long walks, and overnight with moderate leaks. Completely dry every time, with nothing visible. According to customer reviews they hold up to 300ml (over half a pint) for a full 12 hours. When I tested them myself, even on my worst 240ml days, I never came close to maxing them out. I ordered my usual size Large and it fit perfectly. No sizing surprises.
Here's what makes them different: the absorbent layers are strategically placed exactly where men leak. Front, back AND inner leg sides. That full coverage means nothing escapes when you sit, stand or move. And despite holding twice as much as other brands, they create no bulk, no nappy feeling, no lines under your trousers. They look exactly like regular boxer briefs you'd buy anywhere.
The OEKO-TEX® certified bamboo fabric kills bacteria naturally, so there was no smell even when wet. The layers wick moisture away from your skin far faster than standard protection, so I didn't feel wet or damp. I was genuinely surprised how dry and comfortable I stayed all day.
The best part? Just wash and reuse them. Straight in the washing machine and they're good to go. They're built to last, too. I've been rotating 4 pairs for several months now, washing them regularly, and they're still going strong. The elastic is snug, the absorbent layer works like day one, and there's no wear on the fabric. Compare that with Depend fading after about a month or Carer falling apart after a few weeks, and Menvault's durability makes them the clear long-term buy.
At £69.95 for a 4-pack (about £17.50 a pair), they're not the cheapest option. But considering they actually work and hold up after months of washing, the cost per wear beats everything else I tested.
Plus, they come with a reusable Guard. Nothing else I tested offers one. You can slip it in for extra protection on heavier days, or leave it out on lighter ones. Total control based on what your day looks like.
I feel like myself again. The active bloke I was before all this started. That's what I paid £70 for. And it was worth every penny.
Just ordered my second pack. Been using these for 4 months after surgery and they've made a real difference. I was using the TENA washable boxers before but they're only rated for drips and the pack literally gives them an expiry date. Fifty washes. These are still going strong. My wife said she can't even tell I'm wearing anything different. That alone was worth it for me.
How do these compare with the TIICHOO ones? I could never get the sizing right with those. Went up a size like the listing said and they were baggy round the legs.
@Graham Same experience. I sized up on their advice and got gaps at the leg openings, then tried my usual size and it gripped at the thighs. Menvault fit true to size for me, my usual Large was spot on, and the coverage runs front, back and inner leg sides so a shifted fit doesn't become a leak. Haven't had a single leak in 3+ months of daily use.
8 months post-op. Tried the cheap Amazon ones first (Carer brand). First wear was fine for the odd dribble, but after one wash they barely absorbed anything, and I'd even sized up. Switched to Menvault in November and wish I'd started here. They actually hold up through washing. Worth the extra money.
Do these work for the gym? I've been cleared to start light exercise but I'm worried about leaks during squats or lifting.
@Colin Yes, I wear them to the gym regularly. They handle stress leaks from lifting better than anything else I tested, and the bamboo stays cooler than the cotton brands, which run warm when you're active. Keep up your pelvic floor exercises too, they make a real difference with stress leaks.
Solid review. I'm 6 weeks post-surgery and comparing brands right now. This breakdown really helps, especially the capacity numbers. Nobody else publishes them side by side like this.
Tried the BEENIUBEE ones before finding this article. Your review has it spot on. They look fine from the outside but you can feel that padding every step, and one small leak went straight out the side while I was sat in a restaurant. Embarrassing doesn't cover it. Switched to Menvault the following week and haven't had a single incident since. The price difference is real, but so is the difference in how they actually work.
What size did you order? I'm between sizes according to their chart.
@Nigel I went with Large based on my waist measurement (35"). Fits perfectly. Not too tight, not too loose. If you're between sizes I'd go with your regular size. They have a money-back guarantee anyway, so there's no risk in trying.
Been using these for 5 months now. What I appreciate most is they don't feel like medical equipment. Just normal underwear that happens to work. Makes dealing with this whole situation a lot easier mentally.
The Guard insert that comes with these is underrated. On heavier days I pop it in for extra coverage, on lighter days I leave it out. No other brand I looked at gives you that flexibility. Makes a big difference when your leaks aren't consistent from one day to the next, which mine definitely aren't.
Finally took the plunge on these after comparing all the options on Amazon. The upfront cost seemed high but the maths works out. The TENA ones I tried first are twenty quid a pair and the pack says they're done after 50 washes. Three months in with Menvault and they're still perfect.
How long do they take to dry after washing? That's been my issue with other reusable brands, especially the cotton ones.
@Keith Hang them up overnight and they're ready by morning. I started with 4 pairs and wash every couple of days. That's plenty to keep rotating without thinking about it.
The no-odour claim is real. I was sceptical because every brand says it. Wore the Menvaults through a full day including a 2-hour walk and there was nothing. That bamboo fabric genuinely does something the cotton alternatives don't. My previous pair had a smell by midday even after a fresh wash. Night and day difference.